Updated November 2026

Finding gifts for gamers who have everything is harder than it sounds. Most players already own the console, the headset, the controller they like and a shelf of games they never finish. What they often lack is something small that makes their hobby more fun: a tool for settling arguments, a way to stay hydrated during long sessions, or a gag gift that gets a laugh on game night. This guide compares six picks that fit that brief. We selected them using a research-based approach: product specifications, brand reputation and the patterns owners tend to report in reviews, with attention to whether each item is useful, giftable and easy to understand at a glance.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1One More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision CoinTOP CHOICEBest overallOne More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision CoinView on Amazon
  2. 2Funny Gifts Belly Button Lint BrushTOP CHOICEBest for gamers who like a laughFunny Gifts Belly Button Lint BrushView on Amazon
  3. 3Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer TumblerTOP CHOICEBest for desk-side drinksGamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer TumblerView on Amazon
  4. 4Cool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Video Game CandleBest for a themed roomCool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Video Game CandleView on Amazon
  5. 5Ultimate Gamer Gift for Men Double Sided Decision Maker CoinBest budget pickUltimate Gamer Gift for Men Double Sided Decision Maker CoinView on Amazon
  6. 6Writes in Ballpoint Ink Farting Ninja Poop PenBest for stocking stuffersWrites in Ballpoint Ink Farting Ninja Poop PenView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
One More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision Coin Settling late-night debates Double-sided coin with a playful message
Ultimate Gamer Gift for Men Double Sided Decision Maker Coin Stress-free decisions at game night Double-sided decision coin
Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler Long sessions at the desk 20 oz stainless steel insulated tumbler
Cool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Video Game Candle Decorating a gaming room Scented candle with a video game theme
Funny Gifts Belly Button Lint Brush White elephant and gag exchanges Novelty lint brush gag gift
Writes in Ballpoint Ink Farting Ninja Poop Pen Stocking stuffers and office pranks Pen that makes a noise when pressed

One More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision Coin

One More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision Coin, Gifts for Gamer Boyfriend, Husband, Men, Gaming Accessories for Men, Game Gifts for Christmas, Valentine's Day, His Birthday

One More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision Coin, Gifts for Gamer Boyfriend, Husband, Men, Gaming Accessories for Men, Game Gifts for Christmas, Valentine's Day, His Birthday

View on Amazon

Best for: Settling late-night debates

This coin suits the gamer who always says “one more game” and needs a light reminder that bedtime is coming. It works well for couples, roommates and squads who argue about starting another round.

Key specs:

  • Double-sided coin with a humorous message on each face
  • Designed as a novelty decision maker
  • Suitable for stocking stuffers and birthday gifts

Pros:

  • Small, lightweight and easy to pack
  • The joke lands with most gamers and their partners
  • Works as both a gift and a conversation starter

Cons:

  • Best as a small add-on rather than a main gift
  • The humor may not appeal to players who prefer a more serious tone

Bottom line: A strong pick for a partner or friend who loves gaming and enjoys a playful reminder to log off.

View on Amazon

Ultimate Gamer Gift for Men Double Sided Decision Maker Coin

Ultimate Gamer Gift for Men - Double Sided Decision Maker Coin for Boyfriend, Husband & Gamers | Stress-Relieving Gaming Accessories for Birthday, Christmas & Valentines Day, Gamer Stocking Stuffer

Ultimate Gamer Gift for Men – Double Sided Decision Maker Coin for Boyfriend, Husband & Gamers | Stress-Relieving Gaming Accessories for Birthday, Christmas & Valentines Day, Gamer Stocking Stuffer

View on Amazon

Best for: Stress-free decisions at game night

This is a practical, low-cost option for groups that waste time deciding which game to play or who picks up the next round of snacks. It also fits gamers who like tactile fidget items.

Key specs:

  • Double-sided decision maker coin
  • Marketed for birthdays, Christmas and stocking stuffers

Pros:

  • Simple, fast and useful during group sessions
  • Inexpensive enough to pair with another gift
  • Easy to slip into a stocking

Cons:

  • Limited functionality beyond the coin itself
  • Works best as an accent rather than a standalone present

Bottom line: Good for a budget-minded gift-giver who wants a practical, low-key item for regular game nights.

View on Amazon

Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler

Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler - Cool Gaming Stuff Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Boys Son Boyfriend, 20 OZ Stainless Steel Insulated Travel Coffee Tumbler Cup

Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler – Cool Gaming Stuff Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Boys Son Boyfriend, 20 OZ Stainless Steel Insulated Travel Coffee Tumbler Cup

View on Amazon

Best for: Long sessions at the desk

Gamers who sit through marathon raids or ranked queues often reach for a drink and find it has gone warm. A 20 oz insulated tumbler keeps coffee or cold drinks at a better temperature for longer, which is why this suits daily desk use.

Key specs:

  • 20 oz capacity
  • Stainless steel, insulated construction
  • Designed as a travel coffee tumbler

Pros:

  • Useful every day, not just during gaming
  • Fits common cup holders and bags
  • Stainless steel is generally easy to clean

Cons:

  • Hand-washing is often recommended to protect the finish
  • Insulation performance varies with lid use and temperature

Bottom line: A practical choice for a gamer who drinks something hot or cold during long sessions and wants a gift they will use daily.

View on Amazon

Cool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Video Game Candle

Cool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men, Guys, Video Game Lovers, PC Gamer, Girl, Teen Boy, Dad, Husband, Boyfriend Funny Video Game Candle, Gaming, Gamer Gifts for Men, Boys, Women

Cool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men, Guys, Video Game Lovers, PC Gamer, Girl, Teen Boy, Dad, Husband, Boyfriend Funny Video Game Candle, Gaming, Gamer Gifts for Men, Boys, Women

View on Amazon

Best for: Decorating a gaming room

A themed candle adds a bit of atmosphere to a gaming setup without taking up much space. It suits gamers who care about their room’s look and want a small decorative touch.

Key specs:

  • Scented candle with a video game theme
  • Marketed for men, boys and gamers of all ages

Pros:

  • Adds ambience to a gaming room
  • Easy to wrap and giftable
  • Appeals to gamers and non-gamers alike

Cons:

  • Scent preferences are personal and hard to predict
  • Candles should never be left unattended while burning

Bottom line: A good fit for a gamer who likes a themed, cozy room and whose partner or friend wants a decorative gift.

View on Amazon

Funny Gifts Belly Button Lint Brush

Funny Gifts Belly Button Lint Brush, Christmas Gag Gifts for Adults, Men, Women, Boyfriend, Husband, White Elephant, Secret Santa, Prank Gift for Person who has Everything (Green/Kraft)

Funny Gifts Belly Button Lint Brush, Christmas Gag Gifts for Adults, Men, Women, Boyfriend, Husband, White Elephant, Secret Santa, Prank Gift for Person who has Everything (Green/Kraft)

View on Amazon

Best for: White elephant and gag exchanges

For a gamer who already has the good gear, a novelty gift can be the most memorable. This lint brush is built for laughs and suits a gift exchange where the goal is to get a reaction.

Key specs:

  • Novelty gag gift design
  • Marketed for adults in white elephant and Secret Santa exchanges

Pros:

  • Reliable laugh in group settings
  • Low stakes if the recipient does not love it
  • Easy to pair with a more practical gift

Cons:

  • Humor is very personal and may not suit everyone
  • Not appropriate for every workplace or family setting

Bottom line: Best for a playful gift exchange where a joke is the point, not a practical upgrade.

View on Amazon

Writes in Ballpoint Ink Farting Ninja Poop Pen

Writes in Ballpoint Ink, Funny Stocking Stuffers for Teen Boys & Girls, Gag Gifts for Kids, Teens & Boys 8-12 Farting Ninja Poop Pen with Punching Arms, Punches & Farts When Pressed

Writes in Ballpoint Ink, Funny Stocking Stuffers for Teen Boys & Girls, Gag Gifts for Kids, Teens & Boys 8-12 Farting Ninja Poop Pen with Punching Arms, Punches & Farts When Pressed

View on Amazon

Best for: Stocking stuffers and office pranks

This pen is a light, silly stocking stuffer. It writes in ballpoint ink and adds a noise-making gag, which makes it a fun addition to a gamer’s stocking or a desk-drawer joke.

Key specs:

  • Writes in ballpoint ink
  • Novelty design that makes a sound when pressed
  • Marketed for teens and kids as well as adults who enjoy jokes

Pros:

  • Inexpensive and easy to slip into a stocking
  • Practical as a pen even when the gag wears thin
  • Good for younger gamers and adults with a silly streak

Cons:

  • The novelty is best for a casual, lighthearted tone
  • Not a meaningful gift on its own

Bottom line: A small, cheerful addition for a stocking or gift bag, especially for a gamer who appreciates silly humor.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Match the gift to how they play

Think about where the gamer spends most of their time. A player who sits at a desk for hours benefits from a drink vessel, while a player who hosts friends may enjoy a game-night accessory. Choosing around the setup they already use tends to produce better results than choosing around the games they own.

Good picks for this: Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler, One More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision Coin

Check the size and fit

For drinkware, check capacity against how the gamer uses it. A 20 oz tumbler fits most cup holders, but it is worth confirming the diameter if the gift is for a car or a shared desk. For novelty items, size matters less than how easily the piece can be shown off.

Good picks for this: Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler, Writes in Ballpoint Ink Farting Ninja Poop Pen

Consider the use case

Ask whether the gift will be used daily, shared at events or kept as decor. Everyday items should be practical, while party gifts can be silly. A decorative item works best when the recipient already has a themed room or enjoys displaying small things.

Good picks for this: Cool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Video Game Candle, Funny Gifts Belly Button Lint Brush

Look at durability

Stainless steel and sturdy construction tend to hold up better than plastic under daily use. For novelty items, check whether the joke depends on a moving part, since those parts can wear out. Manufacturers usually specify materials, so reading the listing before purchase is worthwhile.

Good picks for this: Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler, Ultimate Gamer Gift for Men Double Sided Decision Maker Coin

Care and handling

Hand-washing is often recommended for insulated drinkware to protect the finish and seals. Candles should be trimmed and never left burning unattended. Following the manufacturer’s care notes helps the gift last and avoids accidents. Worth reading next: Gifts for Gardeners Who Have Everything UK: 5 Best Picks (2026).

Good picks for this: Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler, Cool Christmas, Birthday Gifts for Gamers Men Video Game Candle

Think about the recipient’s sense of humor

Gag gifts work when the recipient enjoys teasing or silliness. Some gamers love self-deprecating jokes, while others prefer a clean, understated gift. If you are unsure, pair a novelty item with a practical one so the gift still lands.

Good picks for this: Funny Gifts Belly Button Lint Brush, Writes in Ballpoint Ink Farting Ninja Poop Pen

FAQ

What counts as a gift for a gamer who has everything?

It is usually something small and useful, a playful item tied to gaming culture, or an everyday accessory that fits their routine. The goal is to add a little fun rather than replace gear they already own.

Are novelty gifts a good idea for gamers?

They can be, especially for game nights, stocking stuffers and white elephant exchanges. Choose a joke the recipient is likely to enjoy, and avoid humor that might feel mean or inappropriate.

How do I choose between a practical and a fun gift?

Think about the recipient’s typical day. If they spend long hours at a desk, a practical item may be more welcome. If they host friends or like playful gifts, a novelty item may land better.

Is a tumbler a good gift for a gamer?

Often yes, because it gets daily use. Check the capacity and whether it fits their cup holders or bag, and follow the care instructions to keep the insulation and finish in good shape.

Should I buy a candle for a gamer?

A candle can be a nice decorative gift, especially for someone who likes a themed room. Scent is personal, so a neutral or theme-based option is often a safer choice. Never leave a lit candle unattended.

How much should I spend on a gift for a gamer who has everything?

Spending should match your relationship and the occasion. Many of the best gifts in this category are small items, so pairing two or three low-cost picks often feels more thoughtful than one large purchase.

Conclusion

For most gamers who already have everything, the best gift is something that adds fun or comfort to a routine they already enjoy. The Gamer Gifts for Men Teen Boys Gaming Gift Gamer Tumbler suits anyone who spends long hours at a desk, while the One More Game or Go to Sleep Gamer Decision Coin is a good match for a partner or friend who needs a playful nudge to log off. For a budget-friendly stocking stuffer, the Ultimate Gamer Gift for Men Double Sided Decision Maker Coin or the ballpoint pen works well. Choose the option that matches how the gamer plays and what kind of humor they enjoy, and a small gift can still feel personal.

Sources

Colin Foster

About Colin Foster

Colin Foster is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our gifts by interest guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.