Updated November 2026
Gifts for gamers who have everything reddit threads are full of advice, but the best ideas usually come down to one thing: giving something a player will use during real sessions instead of another item that sits on a shelf. This guide shows you how to find that gap, what to look for in a gift, and which categories tend to land well with experienced players who already own the console, the headset and the controller they want.
Why “Has Everything” Gamers Are Hard to Shop For
Most seasoned players have already upgraded the obvious items. They own a good headset, a comfortable controller and a stack of games. What they often lack is the small, specific upgrade that removes friction from their routine. Redditors in gaming communities frequently point out that the best gifts solve a problem the player has mentioned but never fixed, such as cable clutter, a sore wrist, or a desk that runs out of space.
Before you buy anything, spend a few minutes looking at how the person plays. Are they a late-night PC player, a couch console gamer, or someone who streams? Each habit points toward different gear.
Step 1: Work Out How They Actually Play
Gaming habits shape which gifts make sense. Use this quick checklist to narrow things down:
- Primary platform: PC, PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo Switch, or mobile
- Session length: short sessions or marathon nights
- Setup: desk, couch, or both
- Social play: solo, online with friends, or competitive ranked play
- Extras: streaming, recording clips, or collecting physical editions
- Complaints they make: sore hands, eye strain, cold rooms, tangled cables, lost controllers
The last item is the most useful. A player who grumbles about a worn thumbstick or a cramped desk is giving you a gift idea for free.
Step 2: Match the Gift Type to the Gap
Once you know the habits, group your options by the kind of problem they solve. The table below compares common gift types by what they fix and who they suit best.
| Gift Type | What It Improves | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort accessories (wrist rests, seat cushions) | Long-session fatigue | Marathon players |
| Cable and desk organization | Clutter and setup time | Desk-based PC players |
| Controller accessories (charging docks, grip covers) | Battery life and wear | Console players |
| Ambient lighting or room lights | Eye strain and mood | Night gamers |
| Physical game media or collector items | Collection pride | Collectors |
| Subscriptions and digital credits | Access to new titles | Players who rotate games often |
| Experiences (tickets, convention passes, tournament entries) | Shared social time | Competitive or social players |
Step 3: Choose From Practical Categories
Comfort Upgrades
Long sessions take a toll on wrists, necks and backs. A quality ergonomic wrist rest or a lumbar cushion for a gaming chair addresses discomfort directly. These work especially well for players who mention stiffness after long nights.
Setup and Organization
Cable management kits, under-desk trays and controller stands reduce clutter. Redditors often praise these because they make a setup look intentional and make it faster to get started. Measure the desk depth first, as a tray that overhangs the edge will not sit correctly.
Controller and Accessory Care
A dedicated charging station, spare cables with a durable braided jacket, or replacement thumbstick caps are practical choices. Check which controller model the player uses, because many accessories are specific to one generation or brand.
Experiences and Subscriptions
If the player already owns everything physical, a subscription to a game service or a tournament entry can feel more special. Choose something tied to a game they already play, or the gift may go unused.
Step 4: Personalize Without Overthinking It
Personal touches help a gift stand out. A custom engraved stand, a themed mousepad with their favorite game art, or a framed screenshot from a memorable match all show you were paying attention. Keep the personalization tied to something specific, such as their main character or a game they finished together.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Buying a game they already own. Check their library or ask a friend before purchasing.
- Choosing the wrong platform. A PlayStation accessory will not work on a PC setup.
- Ignoring compatibility. Confirm model numbers, connector types and wireless standards.
- Giving something that adds clutter. Small, functional items are usually safer than large décor.
- Skipping the gift receipt. Even good gifts sometimes need a different size or color.
Tips for a Better Gift
- Ask a mutual friend what the player has been talking about lately.
- Look at their recent gameplay or streams for hints about frustrations.
- Consider consumables or upgrades that replace something worn out.
- Pair a small physical gift with a short handwritten note explaining why you chose it.
Recommended Gear
These product types consistently appear in gaming gift discussions because they solve common problems for experienced players.
- Ergonomic wrist rest: Supports the wrist during long mouse and keyboard sessions. Look for memory-foam or gel fill and a width that matches the keyboard. View on Amazon
- Under-desk cable tray: Holds power strips and excess cable length out of sight, which helps a desk look clean. Measure desk depth before buying. View on Amazon
- Dual controller charging dock: Keeps two controllers charged and stored in one spot, reducing the search for a cable. Confirm it fits the controller model. View on Amazon
- Adjustable gaming chair lumbar cushion: Adds lower-back support to an existing chair, which helps players who sit for hours. View on Amazon
FAQ
What are good gifts for gamers who have everything?
Practical upgrades that solve a daily problem work best, such as comfort accessories, cable organization, controller charging gear, or experiences tied to games they already play.
Should I buy a game for an experienced gamer?
Only if you know they do not own it and want it. Check their library or ask a friend first, since duplicate purchases are a common complaint.
How do I find out what gear a gamer already owns?
Look at their setup during a visit, check public profile pages on platforms where they show their library, or ask a close friend or family member discreetly.
Are physical gifts better than digital ones?
Neither is better overall. Physical items suit players who enjoy setup and collecting, while digital credits or subscriptions suit players who rotate through many titles.
What if I cannot tell which platform they use?
Ask a friend, check recent messages or social posts for mentions, or choose a platform-neutral gift such as a comfort accessory, a gift card to a digital store, or a snack and drink set for game nights.
How much should I spend on a gamer?
Choose based on your relationship and what you can comfortably afford. Thoughtful, useful gifts often matter more than size or novelty.
Can I return a gaming accessory if it does not fit?
Check the retailer’s return window and whether opened electronics are eligible. Including a gift receipt makes exchanges easier.
What if a gamer says they want nothing?
Choose a small consumable, such as a bag of favorite snacks or a quality drink set for late sessions, or a note with a shared experience like a planned co-op evening.
Conclusion
The most successful gifts for gamers who have everything reddit threads recommend share one trait: they solve a real problem the player already has. Start by observing how they play, match a gift type to the gap you find, and check compatibility before buying. For more ideas, see 6 Best Gifts for Gamers Who Have Everything: Our Picks Compared (2026) and Gifts for Pc Gamers Reddit: 8 Picks Redditors Actually Recommend.

