Updated November 2026

Shopping for gifts for mystery book lovers can feel tricky, because mystery readers tend to have specific tastes: some want clever bookish accessories, some want playful novelty items, and others want something to keep their hands busy between chapters. This list focuses on five products that match the way mystery and thriller fans actually read. We compared each item on listing details, stated materials and quantities, the range of recipients it suits, and the patterns owners tend to describe in feedback. Nothing here is a lab result; it is a research-based shortlist designed to help you match a gift to a reader.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Blind Date with a Book,Blind Books Date,Book Lovers Gifts for Women FaTOP CHOICEBest overallBlind Date with a Book,Blind Books Date,Book Lovers Gifts for Women FaView on Amazon
  2. 2Punchkins Book Plushie - Easily Distracted by a Good Mystery, Gift forTOP CHOICEBest for gift-givers on a schedulePunchkins Book Plushie – Easily Distracted by a Good Mystery, Gift forView on Amazon
  3. 3True Crime Bookmarks Gifts - 100 Pcs Mystery Thriller Paper Bookmark HTOP CHOICEBest budget pick for a big groupTrue Crime Bookmarks Gifts – 100 Pcs Mystery Thriller Paper Bookmark HView on Amazon
  4. 4True Crime Book Marks with Tassels, Mystery Thriller Lover Gifts 4PCSBest for a themed bookmark setTrue Crime Book Marks with Tassels, Mystery Thriller Lover Gifts 4PCSView on Amazon
  5. 5Murder Mystery Coloring Book: A Perfect Murder Mystery Lover Gift withBest for a hands-on puzzle fanMurder Mystery Coloring Book: A Perfect Murder Mystery Lover Gift withView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

The table below gives a quick side-by-side view. Read the individual sections for the details that matter most, such as what each item is made of and who it suits best.

Product Best for Key feature
Blind Date with a Book (Mystery/Thriller) Readers who like surprises Wrapped mystery book selection
Punchkins Book Plushie Readers who enjoy a laugh Plush toy with a bookish joke
True Crime Bookmarks Gifts (100 pcs) Large groups and classrooms High bookmark count
True Crime Book Marks with Tassels (4 pcs) Readers who want themed accessories Acrylic crime-scene styling
Murder Mystery Coloring Book Readers who like to unwind Coloring pages with dark humor

Blind Date with a Book, Blind Books Date, Book Lovers Gifts for Women Family Friends or Yourself, Book Themed Bookish Gifts for Book Lovers (Mystery/Thriller)

Blind Date with a Book,Blind Books Date,Book Lovers Gifts for Women Family Friends or Yourself,Book Themed Bookish Gifts for Book Lovers (Mystery/Thriller)

Blind Date with a Book,Blind Books Date,Book Lovers Gifts for Women Family Friends or Yourself,Book Themed Bookish Gifts for Book Lovers (Mystery/Thriller)

View on Amazon

Best for: Readers who enjoy being surprised by a story they did not pick themselves.

This blind-date-style book gift suits someone who already reads widely and likes trying new authors. The wrapped format removes the pressure of choosing, which makes it a practical option when you know the reader’s general genre but not their current to-read list.

Key specs

  • Themed for mystery and thriller readers, as stated in the listing name
  • Wrapped presentation designed to hide the title until opened
  • Intended for women, family members, friends, or the buyer’s own shelf

Pros

  • Works as a low-risk gift when your knowledge of the reader’s favorite authors is limited
  • Adds an element of play to the unwrapping moment
  • Easy to pair with a bookmark or a small snack for a fuller present

Cons

  • The book is a surprise, so a reader who already owns the title may need to exchange it
  • Recipients who strongly prefer a specific subgenre may find the selection less tailored

Bottom line: A strong pick for mystery readers who like surprises and for gift-givers who want something personal without needing to know the exact title.

View on Amazon

Punchkins Book Plushie – Easily Distracted by a Good Mystery, Gift for Book Lovers, Silly Plush Toy for Gifting

Punchkins Book Plushie - Easily Distracted by a Good Mystery, Gift for Book Lovers, Silly Plush Toy for Gifting

Punchkins Book Plushie – Easily Distracted by a Good Mystery, Gift for Book Lovers, Silly Plush Toy for Gifting

View on Amazon

Best for: Readers who appreciate a lighthearted joke and want a desk or shelf accessory.

This plush toy suits mystery fans who enjoy bookish humor, especially the familiar experience of losing track of time while reading. It works well for coworkers, friends, or a reader who keeps a collection of quirky bookish décor.

Key specs

  • Plush toy designed as a gift for book lovers, as stated in the listing name
  • Bookish slogan referencing mystery reading
  • Intended for gifting across a range of ages and reading tastes

Pros

  • Easy to wrap and send, with no sizing or fit concerns
  • Gives the reader something to display or hug during a long read
  • Pairs well with a book or bookmark in the same gift

Cons

  • Plush items are less useful for readers who prefer minimalist décor
  • Not a reading accessory in the functional sense, so it is best as a sentimental or humorous add-on

Bottom line: A good choice when you want a playful, low-effort gift that signals you understand the reader’s habits.

View on Amazon

True Crime Bookmarks Gifts – 100 Pcs Mystery Thriller Paper Bookmark Horror Book Marks Page Clips Reading Accessories for Women Men Book Lovers Students Teachers Bookish Office Supplies

True Crime Bookmarks Gifts - 100 Pcs Mystery Thriller Paper Bookmark Horror Book Marks Page Clips Reading Accessories for Women Men Book Lovers Students Teachers Bookish Office Supplies

True Crime Bookmarks Gifts – 100 Pcs Mystery Thriller Paper Bookmark Horror Book Marks Page Clips Reading Accessories for Women Men Book Lovers Students Teachers Bookish Office Supplies

View on Amazon

Best for: Large groups, classrooms, book clubs, and readers who go through bookmarks quickly.

Mystery readers often lose track of their place, and a large supply of themed bookmarks is useful for a whole book club or a classroom library. The 100-piece count makes this a practical bulk option. A related read: 5 Best Gifts for Book Club Lovers Who Read Every Month (2026).

Key specs

  • 100 pieces per set, as stated in the listing name
  • Paper bookmark design with a mystery and thriller theme
  • Suitable for women, men, students, teachers, and office use, per the listing

Pros

  • Large quantity covers many gifts or a full group
  • Works as both a reading accessory and a desk or office supply
  • Easy to slip into cards or add to a larger gift basket

Cons

  • Paper bookmarks can bend or wear over time if stored loosely
  • A single bulk set may feel impersonal as a solo gift for one reader

Bottom line: The best pick for group gifting or for a reader who wants a steady supply of bookmarks.

View on Amazon

True Crime Book Marks with Tassels, Mystery Thriller Lover Gifts 4PCS Crime Scene Acrylic Bookmark Set

True Crime Book Marks with Tassels, Mystery Thriller Lover Gifts 4PCS Crime Scene Acrylic Bookmark Set

True Crime Book Marks with Tassels, Mystery Thriller Lover Gifts 4PCS Crime Scene Acrylic Bookmark Set

View on Amazon

Best for: Readers who want a small, themed set of bookmarks with a more finished look.

This smaller set focuses on a crime-scene aesthetic and includes tassels, which many readers find easier to use with thick paperbacks. It suits someone who collects bookish accessories and likes coordinated pieces.

Key specs

  • Set of four bookmarks, as stated in the listing name
  • Acrylic material, per the listing name
  • Tassel attachment and a crime-scene theme

Pros

  • Acrylic construction is generally more durable than thin paper
  • Tassels make the bookmark easy to spot and pull out
  • A four-piece set works well as a complete gift without feeling excessive

Cons

  • Acrylic can feel heavier than paper in a thin paperback
  • Four pieces may run out quickly for a reader who goes through many books

Bottom line: A good fit for a mystery reader who wants a themed, durable bookmark set rather than a bulk supply.

View on Amazon

Murder Mystery Coloring Book: A Perfect Murder Mystery Lover Gift with True Crime Funny Quotes and Simple Coloring Pages

Murder Mystery Coloring Book: A Perfect Murder Mystery Lover Gift with True Crime Funny Quotes and Simple Coloring Pages

Murder Mystery Coloring Book: A Perfect Murder Mystery Lover Gift with True Crime Funny Quotes and Simple Coloring Pages

View on Amazon

Best for: Readers who like to unwind with a hands-on activity away from the page.

Many mystery fans read intensely, then want something calmer before bed. A coloring book with dark-humor quotes gives them a low-pressure outlet that still fits their taste.

Key specs

  • Coloring book with simple pages, as stated in the listing name
  • Includes true crime themed quotes, per the listing
  • Designed as a gift for murder mystery lovers

Pros

  • Offers a relaxing break between dense or suspenseful chapters
  • Humorous quotes add personality that most gift-givers find easy to appreciate
  • Simple pages suit adults who have not colored in years

Cons

  • Readers who prefer detailed or advanced coloring may find the pages too basic
  • Coloring supplies are not included, so pairing with pencils or markers is advisable

Bottom line: The right choice for a reader who wants a calming hobby with a clear mystery theme.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Choosing among gifts for mystery book lovers gets easier once you know which factors matter most. Use the points below to narrow your options before you buy.

Know the Reader’s Format Preference

Some mystery fans read paperbacks in bed, others use e-readers on commutes, and some keep physical copies on display. A bookmark suits paper readers, while a plush toy or coloring book fits readers who enjoy décor or downtime activities. Matching the gift to the format prevents it from ending up in a drawer.

Good picks for this: True Crime Book Marks with Tassels, Punchkins Book Plushie A related read: 6 Best Gifts for Female Book Lovers Who Read Every Night (2026).

Consider Quantity and Use Case

A single gift for one reader calls for a different quantity than a gift for a club or classroom. Bulk sets make sense for groups, while smaller sets feel more personal for one person. Decide who will use the item before you pick a count.

Good picks for this: True Crime Bookmarks Gifts, True Crime Book Marks with Tassels

Check Materials and Durability

Paper bookmarks are inexpensive but can bend, while acrylic versions hold their shape better. For a reader who uses bookmarks daily, sturdier materials usually last longer. Look for the material named in the listing before you order.

Good picks for this: True Crime Book Marks with Tassels, True Crime Bookmarks Gifts

Think About the Reader’s Sense of Humor

Mystery readers often enjoy dark or ironic humor, but tone varies. A playful plush or a quote-filled coloring book suits someone who appreciates a joke, while a more subdued reader may prefer a plain bookmark set. Knowing the reader’s taste keeps the gift from feeling forced.

Good picks for this: Punchkins Book Plushie, Murder Mystery Coloring Book

Plan for Surprise Versus Control

Blind-date-style books are fun for readers who like discovery, but they carry a risk of duplicates. If you are unsure what the reader already owns, a surprise item may need a gift receipt. Consider the reader’s comfort with surprises before choosing this route.

Good picks for this: Blind Date with a Book, Murder Mystery Coloring Book

Match Care and Storage Needs

Plush toys need dusting, coloring books need flat storage, and bookmarks should stay away from humidity and direct sun, which can fade printed designs over time. Simple care keeps the gift looking good for years.

Good picks for this: Punchkins Book Plushie, True Crime Bookmarks Gifts

Plan the Presentation

A gift becomes memorable when it arrives in a thoughtful package. Pair a bookmark or coloring book with a favorite snack or a short handwritten note mentioning a book the reader loved. Presentation matters as much as the item itself.

Good picks for this: Blind Date with a Book, True Crime Book Marks with Tassels

FAQ

What makes a good gift for a mystery book lover?

A good gift fits how the reader actually uses books. Bookmarks suit everyday readers, surprise books suit people who like discovery, and coloring books suit readers who want to unwind. Matching the item to the reader’s habits matters more than picking the most elaborate option.

Are bookmarks a safe choice if I do not know the reader well?

Bookmarks are a low-risk choice because most readers use them regularly. A themed set with a mystery or thriller design signals that you understand the genre without requiring deep knowledge of their favorite authors.

Should I buy a blind-date book or a plushie?

It depends on the reader. A blind-date book works for someone who enjoys surprises and would appreciate a new title. A plushie suits someone who enjoys humor and décor. If the reader is particular about which books they own, a non-book gift may be the safer option.

How many bookmarks should I buy?

For one reader, a four-piece set is usually enough to start. For a book club, classroom, or large group, a bulk pack of around one hundred pieces covers many people. Consider how quickly the recipient goes through bookmarks.

Are coloring books good for adults who read a lot?

Yes, many adults use coloring as a way to relax after long reading sessions. Simple pages with humorous quotes tend to appeal to people who want a calm activity that still fits their interests.

Do I need to include supplies with a coloring book?

Coloring books usually do not include pencils or markers, so pairing one with a set of colored pencils or fine-tip markers makes the gift feel complete. Check the reader’s preferred medium if you can.

How do I keep a plush gift in good shape?

Plush toys do best when kept dry and dusted gently. Spot clean with a damp cloth when needed, and avoid placing the toy in direct sunlight for long periods to reduce fading.

Conclusion

The right gift depends on the reader’s habits. For someone who loves surprises, the blind-date book is a strong choice. For a reader who enjoys humor on the desk, the plushie adds personality. Gift-givers buying for a group should look at the 100-piece bookmark set, while a reader who wants a durable, themed accessory will likely prefer the acrylic tassel set. For a relaxing hobby after long reading sessions, the coloring book fits well. Match the item to how the reader spends their time, and the gift is far more likely to get used.

Sources

Colin Foster

About Colin Foster

Colin Foster is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our gifts by interest guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.